... Skip to main content

QQ Engineering & Consulting Private Limited

Appointed as the Owner's Engineering project for a utility-scale Solar PV plant from Torrent Power. | Independent and Quality Focused Engineering and Consulting. | Delivered Solar PV Plant- 1.7 GW Pre-Bid Engineering in Middle East. | Executed 33/400 kV Multiple Pooling Substation Pre-bid Engineering Support To One of India’s Leading Developer. | Executed 10 MW (AC) PV + BESS Project Engineering in USA. | Completed Multiple Project Power System Studies and Grid Integration Studies.

Blog Details

Home / Blog Details

Insulation Coordination Studies: Methodology, Standards and PSCAD-Based EMT Analysis

Insulation Coordination Studies: Methodology, Standards and PSCAD-Based EMT Analysis

Lightning discharges and high-voltage switching events can seriously stress equipment in power systems. Conducting thorough insulation coordination studies can ensure equipment can cope with these moments of dielectric stress safely and reliably.

Developed for power system engineers, project developers and engineering, procurement and construction (EPC) teams, this guide addresses the evaluation, structure and application of insulation coordination among the many types of power system studies.

What Is an Insulation Coordination Study?

An insulation coordination study is an engineering process by which electrical equipment is chosen for its dielectric strength relative to the voltages and spikes expected on the network based upon the service and the surge protection devices available.

The cost of technical reliability and capital expenditures are balanced by the choice of the amount of insulation to be specified in order to avoid a faulty dielectric, equipment failure and outage; and the amount of insulation to be specified overstates procurement and civil structural costs. As per international standards such as IEC 60071-1, this process matches the withstand ratings of equipment against those of surge arresters, in order to achieve an acceptable risk of failure.

Renewable power plants of utility size and transmission lines require a careful insulation matching system. Collectors, cables and high-voltage grid connections are frequently switched, de-energised, or struck by lightning in large geographic regions.

This means that power transformers, circuit breakers, underground cables and gas-insulated switchgear (GIS) will not be prone to loss or failure at elevated dielectric levels. By planning these studies for solar PV plant engineering, wind power plant engineering and pooling substation engineering you can prevent the premature aging of insulation, determine the distances between components and set equipment specifications without over-designing.

Insulation coordination evaluates four distinct overvoltage classifications, as outlined below:

Overvoltage ClassTypical OriginTypical Mitigation
Temporary Overvoltage (TOV)Earth faults, sudden load rejection, system resonanceSystem grounding design, rapid fault clearance, continuous arrester voltage selection
Slow-Front OvervoltageLine and transformer energisation, capacitor bank switchingClosing resistors, controlled point-on-wave switching, station surge arresters
Fast-Front OvervoltageDirect lightning strikes, shielding failures, back-flashoversOverhead shielding wires, low tower-footing resistance, surge arresters
Very-Fast-Front OvervoltageDisconnector and circuit breaker operations within GISDamping resistors, optimized busbar layout

Also, the signal voltage of transient recovery (TRV) indicates the severe voltage stress present over the opening contacts of the circuit breaker during fault break; it is very important to determine under specialised circuit breaker duties.

A typical insulation coordination study follows a six-step engineering process:

  1. Collect Data and Define Scope: Collect single-line diagrams, equipment layout plans, manufacturer insulation withstand levels, surge arrester datasheets, overhead line parameters, cable geometry and grid equivalent source impedances.
  2. Build the EMT Model: Build a high-frequency electromagnetic transient model with busbars, transformers, transmission spans, towers, footing resistors and non-linear arrester profiles.
  3. Simulate Overvoltage Events: Simulate critical scenarios such as lightning strikes to lines and gantries, energisation delays, load loss and line-to-ground failures.
  4. Determine Representative Overvoltages (Voranzeigen): Identify peak voltage, wavefront steepness and wave shapes at critical nodes in the electrical installation.
  5. Select Rated Surge Arresters and Verify Margins: Select the surge arrester ratings, including continuous voltage and energy absorption and check the margins of protection against equipment basic impulse level (BIL) ratings.
  6. Report and Provide Recommendations: Form an engineering report listing the location of the arresters, the withstand level and the civil separation requirements.

Surge arresters serve as the primary form of protection against transient overvoltage. The protective level of the arrester should not be higher than the equipment’s ability to withstand (basic lightning impulse insulation level) (BIL), where BIL means the highest withstand voltage for the equipment in the normal fast-front impulse tests.

Engineers compare the continuous voltage of an arrester to the expected temporary overvoltage to prevent a thermal runaway. The energy absorbed by the arrester must be large enough to withstand the most intense discharge and the arresters should be placed near the power transformer and the bushings on the inlet lines to prevent inductive drop in lead wire voltage.

Fast-front lightning and sharp switching transients have high frequencies that steady-state or fundamental frequency root mean square (RMS) methods cannot capture. Electromagnetic transient (EMT) simulation simulates the high-frequency properties of distributed-parameter transmission lines, frequency-dependent underground cables, non-linear transformer cores and circuit breaker arcs.

QQEC also offers PSCAD software to conduct insulation coordination studies. Further, QQEC models renewable generation plants and complex grid networks in both RMS and EMT simulation environments, which meet the load dispatch centre (LDC) and transmission system operator (TSO) interconnection requirements. Developers can request comprehensive power system studies services to assess system stability, integration analysis and network compliance. Technical researchers can find details on engineering methods in PSCAD Knowledge Base Article 458.

Insulation coordination practices are governed by international standards organizations:

StandardEdition and StatusScope Covered
IEC 60071-1Edition 9.0 (2019)Definitions, principles and standard insulation withstand rules
IEC 60071-2Edition 5.0 (2023)Application guidelines for calculating withstand levels and margins
IEC TR 60071-4Technical Report (2004)Computational guidelines for transient overvoltages and modelling
IEEE C62.82.2-2022Active (supersedes IEEE 1313.2-1999)Guide for the application of insulation coordination in power systems

Individual projects follow the specific edition and revision named in the statutory grid code or employer’s technical specification.

The primary international standard is IEC 60071-1 (Definitions, principles and rules), the application guide IEC 60071-2 and the technical report IEC TR 60071-4 for computations.

The insulation coordination in power systems is to determine the maximum dielectric resistance of the equipment to protect the network against overvoltages at an economically acceptable risk.

Key inputs include a single-line diagram of the system, the layout of the substation, equipment withstand levels, line and cable geometry, surge arrester properties, tower footing resistances and an equivalent upstream short circuit.

QQEC uses PSCAD software to perform insulation coordination studies.

QQ Engineering & Consulting Private Limited  is an independent engineering consultancy delivering advanced power system studies and electromagnetic transient analysis for utility-scale substations, solar and wind plants. Learn more about our specialised power system studies services, or contact QQEC’s engineering team, who will review your project specifications and grid-connection requirements.

Author

Have an Upcoming Renewable Energy Project?

Get expert engineering support for Solar PV, BESS, Wind, Grid Integration, Substations & Power System Studies.